Today, I’m going to talk about visual arts. Well, at least that’s where I’m going to start. Knowing myself, I’ll probably end up talking about school, grades, teachers, classmates, math, and possibly the Roman army. But that’s just how my brain works sometimes. One topic leads to another, and suddenly I’m discussing something completely different. Anyway, let’s start with visual arts, because there’s something about it that I find particularly interesting, and honestly, a little frustrating.
The thing about visual arts is that it’s not like most other classes. In math, for example, there’s usually a right answer and a wrong answer. You solve the problem, you show your work, and boom, you either got it right or you didn’t. Simple enough. But in visual arts, things get a lot more complicated. What exactly makes a piece of art good? Who gets to decide? And more importantly, how are you supposed to give someone a fair grade when the thing you’re grading is based so heavily on opinion?
Think about it. Someone could draw a flying duck, and one person might think it’s the greatest flying duck in the history of flying ducks. Another person might look at the exact same drawing and think it looks like a potato with wings. Who’s right? Technically, neither of them is completely right or wrong. That’s the problem with art. There isn’t always a correct answer. There’s just what people think, and people can think very different things.
Now, I’m not saying visual arts shouldn’t be taught or that teachers shouldn’t evaluate students. I actually think art is interesting, and there’s definitely skill involved. But I do think grading art is a particularly tricky business. If you’re judging someone’s work entirely by how much you personally like it, that doesn’t seem very fair. What if the student worked incredibly hard on something that just happens not to match your taste? Does that mean the student deserves a bad grade? I don’t think so.
In my opinion, visual arts should be graded more on effort, improvement, creativity, and the process of making something. Did the student actually try? Did they experiment with different ideas? Did they take the assignment seriously? Did they improve from where they started? Those are things you can actually observe. You might not be able to prove that a painting is beautiful, but you can usually tell whether someone spent time thinking about it and working on it. At least, that makes more sense to me than giving someone a mysterious grade because their drawing wasn’t exactly your favorite.
Of course, effort alone probably shouldn’t guarantee a perfect grade either. I understand that. If someone spends three hours drawing a circle, that doesn’t automatically make it the greatest circle ever created. There are still techniques to learn, instructions to follow, and skills to develop. But I think effort should count for something, especially when the assignment involves creativity. Otherwise, what exactly are we encouraging students to do? Make something original, or just figure out what the teacher likes and copy that?
That brings me to grading in general, which is another thing I have quite a few opinions about. I think grades should be specific rather than vague. If I get a bad grade, I want to know why. Did I misunderstand something? Did I forget an important part? Was my explanation unclear? Fine. Tell me that, and I can work on it. What I don’t particularly enjoy is getting a grade that feels like it came out of nowhere. I have a name for that: random grading. And random grading is something I would very much prefer not to experience.
To be clear, I’m not against bad grades. If I make mistakes, I make mistakes. If I forget to do something important, then I understand why points might be taken away. I’m not expecting every teacher to hand me an A just because I showed up and looked reasonably intelligent. That would be ridiculous. What I want is a grade that actually represents what I did. If I worked hard and did well, I want that to be recognized. If I didn’t do well, I want to understand what went wrong. A grade should tell you something useful, not just make you feel happy or miserable for five minutes.
Sometimes I also wonder how teachers decide whether someone is putting in enough effort. That seems difficult too, because effort isn’t always obvious. Some people work very quietly. Some people look busy but aren’t actually accomplishing much. And some people might be struggling with something that looks easy to everyone else. So maybe teachers have a harder job than I originally thought. Still, I think the goal should be to make grading as fair and understandable as possible. Nobody wants to feel like their work was ignored, especially when they genuinely tried.
Writing is another subject where things get complicated. In language arts, there are definitely things you can grade objectively, like grammar, spelling, structure, and whether someone actually answered the question. But writing also involves ideas, style, and interpretation. Two people can write completely different essays about the same topic, and both might be good. One person might be very serious and organized, while another might be more creative and unusual. Does that automatically make one better? Not necessarily. That’s why I think clear expectations are important. Otherwise, writing can start to feel a little like visual arts, except instead of drawing a flying duck, you’re trying to explain your thoughts in five paragraphs.
Math, on the other hand, is a different story. I wouldn’t say math is my favorite thing in the entire universe, because that would be a bit dramatic. I like math, but I don’t love-love math every single second of my life. Sometimes it’s interesting, sometimes it’s frustrating, and sometimes I would rather be doing almost anything else. But I do appreciate that math usually gives you something definite to work toward. There’s a problem, there’s a method, and there’s an answer. Even when the problem is difficult, at least you know what you’re trying to accomplish.
Would I do extra math if someone asked me? That’s actually a surprisingly complicated question. My answer would probably be yes and no at the same time. Yes, because solving something challenging can be satisfying, especially when you finally understand it. No, because sometimes I would rather not spend my free time staring at numbers. Both answers are completely reasonable, in my opinion. I think it’s possible to enjoy a subject without wanting to do it twenty-four hours a day. Apparently, that’s a concept people sometimes find difficult to understand.
Another thing I’ve been thinking about is how much school changes as you get older. When you’re younger, everything seems simpler. The assignments are easier, the expectations are lower, and sometimes learning feels more like playing. You do an activity, you have some fun, and everyone goes home reasonably happy. But as you get older, school starts becoming much more serious. Suddenly there are deadlines, complicated instructions, detailed rubrics, and assignments that require you to think about seventeen different things at once. I’m exaggerating, obviously, but only a little.
I understand why school gets harder. We’re getting older, and we’re supposed to become more independent. That’s perfectly reasonable. But sometimes I wonder why getting older seems to mean that everything has to become less fun. Why can’t something be challenging and enjoyable at the same time? Why does learning sometimes have to feel like a giant machine that produces assignments, grades, and more assignments? I don’t think education should be easy all the time, but I also don’t think difficulty automatically makes something better.
One thing I’ve realized is that school requires stamina. Not the kind of stamina you need for swimming or running, although I suppose those are useful too. I’m talking about the ability to keep working even when you’re tired, distracted, or not particularly interested in what you’re doing. That’s actually pretty difficult. It’s easy to say, “Just focus,” but focusing for an entire school day is a different matter. You have to listen, think, write, solve problems, remember instructions, and somehow still have enough energy to function afterward. Sometimes I think school is basically an endurance sport, except instead of running laps, you’re running through assignments.
And then there are classmates. Now, I don’t want to sound like I’m judging everyone around me, because I’m definitely not perfect myself. I get distracted. I get bored. Sometimes I don’t feel like working either. But I do find it interesting how differently people approach school. Some students seem incredibly motivated, while others are much more relaxed about everything. Some people care a lot about grades, and others seem perfectly happy as long as they pass. I don’t necessarily think one attitude explains everything about a person, but the differences can be pretty fascinating.
What I sometimes find frustrating is when people say they want good grades but don’t seem interested in doing the work required to get them. I mean, I understand wanting good results. Who doesn’t? But there’s usually a connection between what you put into something and what you get out of it. Not a perfect connection, obviously. Sometimes you work hard and still struggle. Sometimes things come easily to someone else. But generally speaking, if you want to improve, you probably have to make an attempt. Preferably more than one attempt.
It’s a pretty simple idea, actually. If you want to get better at math, practice math. If you want to become a better writer, write. If you want to improve at swimming, you probably have to get into the pool instead of standing next to it and thinking about how wonderful swimming would be. I don’t think you need to be a genius to understand that. You just need to be willing to try. And I think trying is something people sometimes underestimate because it sounds so ordinary. But ordinary things can be surprisingly important.
Of course, I also know that not everyone finds the same things easy. Something that takes me ten minutes might take someone else an hour, and something I struggle with might be ridiculously simple for another person. That’s just how people work. We have different strengths, different interests, and different ways of learning. So I don’t think it’s fair to judge someone’s intelligence based on one assignment or one bad day. What matters more to me is whether someone is willing to learn, improve, and take responsibility for what they’re doing.
Behavior is another interesting part of school. Sometimes I genuinely don’t understand why following a simple instruction can become such a complicated event. Take lining up, for example. The teacher says, “Everyone, line up,” and you would think that would be the end of the story. Everyone lines up, we go wherever we’re supposed to go, and life continues. Beautiful. Efficient. Civilization at its finest.
But no. Somehow, lining up can turn into an entire production. People are talking, wandering around, standing in the wrong place, or doing practically everything except lining up. And then the teacher has to repeat the instructions, and suddenly we’re spending several minutes doing something that should have taken about twenty seconds. I don’t know about everyone else, but lining up is not exactly my favorite recreational activity. I have never woken up in the morning thinking, “Wow, I really hope we get to practice standing in a line today.”
I find it especially funny when people complain about having to repeat something after not following the instructions the first time. I mean, isn’t that kind of the reason we’re repeating it? If everyone had just done it properly, we’d probably be finished already. It’s not a particularly complicated mystery. Sometimes I wish we could all agree to cooperate for thirty seconds and then return to whatever interesting things we were doing before. That would make life considerably easier.
At the same time, I don’t think every problem with school behavior is automatically the students’ fault. Teachers have a responsibility too. I think students are much more willing to listen when they feel like the adults are listening to them. If a teacher explains why something matters, rather than simply saying, “Because I said so,” that usually makes a difference. At least it does for me. I don’t mind rules when the rules make sense. What frustrates me is when something feels unnecessary and nobody seems interested in explaining it.
I’ve actually had very different experiences with teachers over the years. Some teachers are strict but fair, and I really respect that. Others rely more heavily on rules and procedures, which can sometimes make school feel a little mechanical. At Beaver, I’ve met teachers who are genuinely nice and seem interested in what students think. I appreciate that because I don’t want school to be a place where adults talk and children simply absorb information like human sponges. I think students should be allowed to ask questions, disagree respectfully, and explain their reasoning.
That doesn’t mean students should get to do whatever they want. Obviously, that would be chaos. Imagine a school where every student could decide whether the rules applied to them. We’d probably spend the entire day negotiating whether lunch should last four hours and whether homework should exist. Actually, now that I think about it, some people might support that idea. But realistically, schools need structure. I just think structure works better when it comes with respect in both directions.
Another thing that interests me is the psychology of school. It’s surprisingly complicated when you really think about it. How do people become friends? Why do certain groups form? Why are some students extremely serious about grades while others barely think about them? Why do people sometimes act completely differently around their friends than they do in class? There’s a whole social system operating inside a school, and most of the time we’re participating in it without even noticing.
Sometimes I think school is almost like a miniature society. You have rules, authority, friendships, disagreements, cooperation, competition, and people with completely different personalities trying to exist in the same building. Some people are natural leaders. Some people prefer to follow. Some people want attention, and others would probably prefer to become invisible for a few minutes. It’s actually pretty intricate, and the more I think about it, the more interesting it becomes.
I also think learning with friends can be a really good thing. When you’re working with people you like, the whole experience can become more enjoyable. You can explain things to each other, compare ideas, and sometimes understand something better because your friend explains it differently from the teacher. Of course, there’s always the possibility that studying with friends turns into talking about completely unrelated things for an hour. That happens too. But when it works, I think learning together can be genuinely useful.
Speaking of completely unrelated things, I’ve also been doing some more research about Roman troops. And I’ve discovered something rather disappointing: being a Roman soldier was not exactly a vacation. There was a tremendous amount of training, marching, discipline, and work involved. When you imagine Roman armies, you might picture impressive formations, shields, swords, and dramatic battles. What you don’t always picture is the exhausting daily routine required to make those armies function. Apparently, being part of a powerful military organization involves doing a lot of things that aren’t particularly entertaining. Who would have guessed?
But I suppose that’s another example of effort. People often admire the results of something without thinking about all the work behind it. An army doesn’t become organized by accident. A swimmer doesn’t become fast by just imagining a perfect race. A student doesn’t become a better writer by staring at a blank page and hoping that a brilliant essay will magically appear. There’s usually a lot of repetitive, sometimes boring work involved. And unfortunately, that’s probably true for almost everything worth getting good at.
The problem is that knowing you should work hard and actually wanting to work hard are two completely different things. I understand that perfectly because I experience it myself. Sometimes I know exactly what I’m supposed to do, and I still don’t particularly feel like doing it. I might be tired, bored, distracted, or just not in the mood. That doesn’t mean I don’t care. It just means I’m a human being, and human beings are not always perfectly efficient machines.
I think that’s why stamina and self-discipline matter so much. You can’t always wait until you feel motivated. Sometimes you just have to start, even if the assignment looks boring or difficult. And once you start, it often becomes easier to continue. Not always, obviously. Some assignments remain boring from beginning to end, and I don’t think there’s any point pretending otherwise. But at least when you finish, you have something to show for your time. That’s better than spending an hour complaining about the work and then still having to do it afterward.
I also don’t think everyone needs to be perfect. Actually, I think expecting perfection is a pretty terrible idea. Nobody is perfect, and pretending otherwise just makes everything more stressful. What matters is making progress. Maybe you don’t understand something today, but you understand a little more tomorrow. Maybe your first attempt is terrible, but your second attempt is better. That’s how learning works. If everyone could do everything perfectly the first time, there wouldn’t be much reason to have schools in the first place.
And this brings me back to grades, because I think grades sometimes make people forget what learning is supposed to be about. A grade is useful when it helps you understand your progress. But if all you’re thinking about is the number or letter at the top of the page, you might miss the actual point. You could get a good grade without learning very much, or you could struggle through something difficult and learn a tremendous amount. Those two situations aren’t always reflected perfectly in a grading system.
I still care about grades, though. I’m not going to pretend I don’t. If I work hard on something, I want to do well. I want to feel proud of the result, and I want to know that my effort actually mattered. But I also want the grade to mean something. I don’t want an A just because someone felt generous, and I don’t want a disappointing grade without understanding why. I want to earn what I get. That seems like a pretty reasonable expectation.
Sometimes I wish students and teachers could talk more openly about these things. Not in a way where everyone argues about every single point, because that would probably take forever. But in a way where students understand the expectations and teachers understand how students experience the work. Maybe a student thinks an assignment is unfair because they misunderstood the instructions. Maybe a teacher doesn’t realize how confusing a particular rubric sounds. A conversation could probably solve some of those problems.
I think that’s one of the biggest differences between simply following instructions and actually learning. Following instructions means doing what someone tells you. Learning means understanding what you’re doing and why you’re doing it. Ideally, school should involve both. You need enough discipline to complete your responsibilities, but you also need enough curiosity to ask questions. Without discipline, nothing gets finished. Without curiosity, everything becomes pretty boring.
And boredom, unfortunately, is something I know quite well. Sometimes I get bored even when I know what I’m doing is important. I don’t think that’s particularly unusual. The real challenge is figuring out what to do about it. You can complain, you can procrastinate, or you can try to make the task more interesting. Personally, I don’t always choose the third option, but I probably should more often. It would save me quite a bit of time.
I’ve also noticed that people sometimes confuse being smart with already knowing everything. I don’t think that’s how intelligence works. Someone can be very intelligent and still make terrible decisions. Someone else might struggle academically but have excellent judgment, creativity, or determination. Being smart isn’t just about answering questions correctly. It’s also about recognizing when you don’t understand something and being willing to figure it out.
That’s something I think all of us, including me, could improve at. We could listen a little more carefully, think before making decisions, and put more effort into things that matter. Not because we’re all doing terribly, but because there’s usually room to improve. I don’t think anyone needs to become some kind of perfect academic superhero. We just need to take our responsibilities seriously enough to give ourselves a fair chance.
And honestly, I think most people are capable of more than they sometimes show. Maybe they haven’t found something that interests them yet. Maybe they’re tired. Maybe they’re having a difficult day, or maybe they simply haven’t figured out how to organize themselves. I don’t know. I’m not inside their brains, which is probably a good thing because managing my own brain is already complicated enough. But I do think people can surprise themselves when they actually decide to try.
School isn’t perfect. I don’t think any school is. There are boring assignments, confusing expectations, occasional disagreements, and moments when you wonder why everyone is making something so much more complicated than it needs to be. But school also gives you opportunities to learn things, meet interesting people, discover what you’re good at, and figure out what kind of person you want to become. That’s actually a pretty big deal when you think about it.
And maybe that’s the most interesting part of school. It’s not just about math, writing, visual arts, or getting a particular grade. It’s about learning how to think, how to work, how to deal with other people, and how to keep going when something isn’t easy. Sometimes those lessons happen during an assignment. Sometimes they happen when you’re talking to a friend. And sometimes, apparently, they happen while you’re standing in a line wondering why nobody else has figured out how lining up works.
So I guess my final point is pretty simple: try your best, be fair to other people, and don’t assume that everything has to have one correct answer. Some things, like math problems, usually do. Other things, like art, writing, and human behavior, are a lot more complicated. And that’s fine. Life would probably be pretty boring if everything worked exactly the same way.
As for me, I’m going to keep asking questions, occasionally complaining about things that don’t make sense, and trying to understand why people do what they do. I’m definitely not perfect, and I don’t expect everyone else to be perfect either. But I do think we can all make a decent attempt at getting better. Because if there’s one thing I’ve learned, it’s that you usually don’t get very far by doing absolutely nothing.
And if someone ever asks me to grade a flying duck, I think I’ll just ask how much effort went into making it.
That seems fair enough. Anyway, that’s it for today. This turned out to be a much longer discussion than I expected, which is becoming a pretty normal thing for me.



Leave a Reply